#15: Plant VS Meat

ROAR aesthetic

As discussions around food, health, and sustainability become increasingly central in modern life, one question continues to divide opinion: Should we eat meat, or adopt a plant-based diet?

From the explosion of vegan influencers to the rise of nose-to-tail carnivore diets, the debate is rarely neutral. But while opinions can be loud, the science presents a more nuanced perspective.

This article breaks down the health, environmental, nutritional, and ethical pros and cons of each approach, helping you make informed decisions that align with your values, biology, and lifestyle.


 

 

The Nutritional Power of Meat

 

Animal products—ranging from red meat and poultry to fish and eggs—are widely consumed for their complete proteins, micronutrient density, and culinary versatility.


Pros of Eating Meat

 

1. Complete Protein Source

Animal protein includes all nine essential amino acids in highly bioavailable ratios. This is particularly beneficial for muscle building, hormonal health, and metabolic function.

NIH on Protein Quality


2. Rich in Vitamin B12

Vitamin B12, vital for neurological function and red blood cell formation, is naturally found only in animal products. Deficiency can cause fatigue, nerve damage, and cognitive issues.

Harvard Health – B12 Deficiency


3. Superior Iron Absorption

Meat contains heme iron, which is more easily absorbed than plant-based non-heme iron. This is particularly important for individuals at higher risk of anemia, such as women of reproductive age.


4. Satiety and Metabolic Support

Protein-rich foods like meat increase satiety and may help regulate appetite and support fat loss, particularly when paired with strength training or resistance exercise.


5. Culinary and Cultural Significance

Meat remains a staple in many traditional diets and carries strong cultural and familial ties, often playing a key role in heritage and ritual.


Cons of Eating Meat

 

1. Potential Links to Chronic Disease

Processed meats and excessive red meat intake have been linked to increased risks of cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, and colorectal cancer.

WHO Classification of Processed Meats as Carcinogenic


2. Environmental Impact

Animal agriculture—especially beef and lamb production—contributes significantly to:


3. Ethical and Welfare Concerns

The reality of factory farming raises serious questions around animal welfare, living conditions, and the use of antibiotics, which may contribute to antibiotic resistance.


4. Health Risks from Overconsumption

Regular overconsumption of fatty cuts and processed meats can raise LDL cholesterol and contribute to inflammation, depending on the individual’s metabolic profile.


 

 

The Rise of Plant-Based Diets

 

A plant-based diet focuses on foods derived from plants, including vegetables, fruits, grains, legumes, nuts, and seeds. It excludes or minimises animal products, depending on the specific variation (vegan, vegetarian, pescatarian, etc.).


Pros of a Plant-Based Diet

1. Lower Risk of Chronic Disease

Numerous studies have linked plant-based diets to a reduced risk of:


2. Improved Gut and Immune Health

Plant foods are high in prebiotic fiber, which nourishes beneficial gut bacteria. A healthy microbiome supports immune function, mood stability, and anti-inflammatory responses.


3. Environmental Sustainability

Compared to animal agriculture, plant-based food production generally requires:


4. Ethical Alignment

Many choose plant-based eating to avoid contributing to animal suffering, environmental exploitation, or industrial-scale farming practices.


Cons of a Plant-Based Diet

 

1. Risk of Nutrient Deficiencies

Without proper planning, plant-based diets can lack:


2. Protein Quality and Quantity

Plant proteins tend to be incomplete and lower in leucine, an amino acid key for muscle protein synthesis. Combining foods (e.g., rice and beans) helps, but higher total intake is often required for athletes or older adults.

3. Heavily Processed Plant Foods

Many commercial plant-based alternatives (e.g., mock meats, vegan cheeses) are ultra-processed, high in refined oils, salt, and additives, reducing their health benefit. A whole-food plant-based approach is generally healthier than processed veganism.

 

4. Social and Cultural Limitations

Plant-based diets may be harder to follow in some regions or cultural settings, where animal products are central to tradition or more accessible than plant-based alternatives.

 

So, Which Diet is Better?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Both diets can be healthy—or unhealthy—depending on how they’re implemented. The key lies in quality, variety, and balance.

  • A well-planned omnivorous diet rich in lean meats, seafood, vegetables, and whole grains can provide comprehensive nutrition.
  • A well-structured plant-based diet, fortified with B12 and including diverse sources of protein and healthy fats, can support long-term health and sustainability.

Rather than choosing sides, some experts advocate for a flexitarian approach—minimising meat but not excluding it, emphasising whole, minimally processed foods from both plants and animals.


 

Health, Ethics, and the Bigger Picture

 

The meat vs. plant-based debate is not just about macros and vitamins—it’s also about ethics, environment, culture, and personal values. While plant-based eating aligns more clearly with sustainability and animal welfare, responsibly sourced meat can provide unique health benefits and cultural connection.

Informed choice is everything. Whether you eat meat, go vegan, or fall somewhere in between, prioritising nutrient-dense, whole foods and avoiding extremes will serve you far better than any trend.

 

 


References and Further Reading

Back to blog

Leave a comment